NIS: working to improve racial equity in city policy decisions

Lynwood Best, right, and Jacob Lerner display a poster highlighting services offered by Neighborhood Improvement services within Northeast Central Durham. (Staff photo by Heaven Gullate)


 

Durham’s Neighborhood Improvement Services (NIS) Community Engagement Team leaders Lynwood Best and Jacob Lerner understand something that many people don’t appreciate — that there is a vast difference between equality and equity.

According to Best and Lerner, equality is making sure everyone is treated equally.

Equity is making sure everyone is given the tools that they need to be successful.

This is why Best and Lerner say they are eager to provide information about their Equitable Community Engagement Blueprint.

The blueprint plan was requested by the City Council last August and presented in November, but it is an evolving document. Best, the Durham Community Engagement Manager, and Lerner, the Community Engagement Coordinator for District One – which includes the Northeast Central Durham neighborhoods, are seeking input from residents.

“We don’t believe that in 90 days, you can actually create a lasting plan that is effective,” Lerner says. “We think that it’ll take a couple years to do the engagement with different community groups, to talk about what all the pieces of the blueprint are, and to highlight different things to see what actually works. But this was our starting point.”

The introduction to the blueprint explains that they hope to outline an “engagement to lead to a racial equity plan” — a result of the previously proposed engagement plan for a Belt Line Trail, a new trail for walking, running and biking.

The Belt Line plan introduced a new trail that would go through some parts of Durham. Citizens began to complain about the lack of inclusivity introduced in previous engagement plans as well as this one.

Other trails, like the R. Kelly Bryant Trail, are set to run through NECD specifically.

Best has worked in communications for over 20 years while Lerner has held his position for three. He says he’s knocked on doors, all told, for 10-15 years.

Lerner explains, “What we did as a team, is we said, ‘It doesn’t make sense to just create an engagement plan specific to this outline,’ because there are projects happening like this all over the city. We want to create a blueprint to see what it looks like to have race equity engrained in engagement.”

The City Council allotted 90 days for the Community Engagement team to bring something to the table that could enhance racial equity.

Lerner expresses his concern about community engagement processes not being inclusive. He says that it’s important to know exactly what groups of people need to lessen equal distribution and heighten equity.

Lerner says, “If we think about all of the development happening in Durham — all of the gentrification that people are concerned about — the root of it is the policies that we created led to it.”  

“There’s engagement for most processes,”  Lerner says,  “and if certain groups aren’t a part of engagement, then the decisions that are being made by the city aren’t inclusive for those groups.”

The beginning of the blueprint explains that if change is be made effectively, resources will have to be invested in different and more equitable ways.

An illustration depicting the differences between equality and equity. This model highlights the need for racial equity, say the leaders of the city’s Neighborhood Improvement Services Community Engagement team. (Photo taken from https://www.durhamcommunityengagement.org/)

Lerner provided this example: If resources were split equally, a well-off Caucasian man, who already has enough, is now receiving the same amount of resources as the poor Hispanic man down the street. The only problem is that now, it’s no longer equal because the white man still has more.

Lerner goes on to explain that he’s realized that they have been doing community engagement on a “color-blind basis.”

“We’ve been engaging and we’ll go to the City Council and we’ll say, ‘we have 800 surveys, and this is what the community wants,’ but when we don’t know who those people are, we accidentally prioritize certain groups,” Lerner said.

            Lerner says that the surveys have been set up this way for years as a way to protect citizen’s privacy and identify, but NIS needs to collect data to see who actually is participating.

            The engagement team will also look beyond race. Age and gender will also be assessed.

            “The experiences of black women are completely different from black men,” Lerner says. “We have to think about the intersection of these things. We need to lead with race but not only talk about race.”

Many citizens have questioned where the funding that will support this new engagement process will come from. Lerner says that the plan is to increase the funds in different ways than before.

 “We are aiming to teach ourselves how to invest money in trusted partnerships, like maybe coordinating with government departments,” he explains. “We also could cut down on the funding that goes into the community meetings.”

            Best suggested that to cut down that cost, they have to reduce the number of meetings per year, adding, “We know that what has been done before is not currently working. We are working on being sensitive to those facts. In order to save government efforts, we have to condense the city meetings, and we have a plan for that.”

            Best and Lerner will be exploring the barriers that stop normal citizens from participating in city meetings and having their voices heard.

            Best and Lerner say their goal is to figure out “what’s stopping them” — whether it be not having child care, transportation, or apathy. Doing this, they hope, will essentially put more people in seats at one meeting, rather than having multiple meetings.

            Best and Lerner stress that NIS is dedicated to improving racial equity in city policy decisions.

           

       

 

            For more information on NIS Community Engagement projects or community events, check out Durham’s Community Engagement website.

 Web links: https://www.durhamcommunityengagement.org/

 

Captions

GullateHeaven_EquityModel.jpg A popular model that perfectly depicts equality vs. equity. This is a valid model for the Community Engagement team’s blueprint because it shows the reason why this project is so important. Right now, the resources are being split equally, lessening racial equity.  (Photo taken from https://www.durhamcommunityengagement.org/)

 

GullateHeaven_Best&Lerner.jpg: Lynwood Best, right, and Jacob Lerner display a poster highlighting services offered by Neighborhood Improvement services within Northeast Central Durham.  (Staff photo by Heaven Gullate)

 

Heaven Gullate is an NCCU student from Gastonia. This spring she is serving as a staff writer for the Durham VOICE.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:

<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>